A professor of journalism at the University of Iowa, Stephen Bloom, has written an article for The Atlantic about life in Iowa. In the piece, he argues that the state is ill-suited to help determine the next president of the United States, declaring, “In a perfect world, no way would Iowa ever be considered representative of America, or even a small part of it. Iowa’s not representative of much.”
This may seem harsh, but Mr. Bloom is just getting started. In his rambling and unfocused 5700-word article, Mr. Bloom has much more to share about Iowa, using descriptors such as “depressed,” “crime-infested,” “slum town,” “polluted,” ”schizophrenic,” “culturally-challenged,” and “bizarre.”
Mr. Bloom seems to have a particular interest in rural Iowa, declaring that, “Those who stay in rural Iowa are often the elderly waiting to die, those too timid (or lacking in educated) (sic) to peer around the bend for better opportunities, an assortment of waste-toids and meth addicts with pale skin and rotted teeth, or those who quixotically believe, like Little Orphan Annie, that “The sun’ll come out tomorrow.”
Wow, and though I don’t know what a “waste-oid” is, I’m betting that it’s not a good thing.
Not surprisingly, Mr. Bloom’s observations have generated many comments and even some anger, but he accepts this as a price to be paid for “raising uncomfortable truths.” In response to the aftermath of his article, he released a statement, which began ““For 40 years as a journalist, I’ve tried to shine a light into dark corners. That’s what good journalists do. They don’t accept what politicians, government bureaucrats, corporate spokespeople say is the truth. Good journalism isn’t just reporting. It’s making observations, trying to make sense out of the world and its shadows — even if readers don’t agree with those observations.”
He throws in a few statistics (usually incorrect and misleading, which I’ll discuss in another post) to show how rural Iowa is a wasteland of broken residents and failed towns, but this is where his argument falls apart.
Iowa should not be condemned for having problems, because every state is facing these same problems in varying degrees. Given that no one state is a perfect representation of our country (and Mr. Bloom doesn’t identify another as a better choice), he seems to use his notion of Iowa’s unsuitability as a primary state as an excuse to unleash his mean-spirited barrage of criticism.
Here’s my advice to Mr. Bloom… move. Find a new home. Live somewhere else. You are very unhappy with your surroundings and neighbors, and you need to find people you like, and who like you. Life is too short.
He may be disappointed, however. Every place has people who are annoying, mean, intolerant, small-minded, selfish, and rude, just like Iowa. Every place is also home to people who are kind, loving, generous, caring, outgoing, and open, just like Iowa. And sometimes all these traits even inhabit the same people. Sort of like family.
If your final, ultimate indictment against Iowa is that people comment during your dog-walking, asking if your yellow Lab “hunts well”, then there are deeper issues at play, and you need to try a new city, to discover and chronicle all its irritating quirks.
(Readers – I am not making this up about the dog-walking. If you have not read the article, I urge you to do so.)
My work is all about data and what it can tell us. So I know that numbers aren’t always what they seem, and they are often misleading either as an accident or part of a larger agenda.
The National Association of Realtors (NAR) announced today that it will be restating home-sales data going back to 2007. (Hey, isn’t that when the housing market started to tank? That’s a coincidence.)
“The Chicago-based organization has known for a long time that the existing home sales data it releases to the public each month were significantly inflated. It knew that it was double-counting, miscounting and relying on outdated census results that pumped up its report on housing activity.” Chicago Tribune, 12/21/11
Just in time for the holidays – which cities have the biggest holiday crush of travelers?
Here are the 100 U.S. cities which show the largest increase in air traveler over the two winter holidays, Thanksgiving and Christmas/New Year (aka the Winter Holidays).
Now, we didn’t just look at raw numbers. The obvious list would just be the cities with the largest populations. Rather, these are the airline destinations ranked by the percent of their air travelers which list the city as their destination which occur during the holidays, as compared to their total annual incoming flights.
Our family went to the movies the other night and saw “The Descendants,” which has been getting a lot of critical acclaim. It’s been described as “surprising, moving and frequently very funny” (New York Times review).
But what a surprise it was to see to my buddy, Laird Hamilton, in a small role as the accidental accomplice in the death of one of the main characters. Laird is a native of Hawaii, and widely recognized as the greatest big-wave surfer in the world. And we’re talking BIG waves; 70-80 feet tall.
A few years ago, Laird and I worked on a campaign for Zest Bodywash, which celebrated my study of the Best Cities for Adventures. During our joint television appearances, Laird spoke about how we can all bring adventure to our own lives, every day. He said you don’t have to risk your life to feel more alive. His suggestions included doing things that were out of our ordinary routine, such as taking a walk barefoot or playing tennis with your other hand.
I recently had a great phone conference with members of the Paso del Norte Group, which “promotes the economic, social and cultural vitality of the El Paso region.”
I spoke with Richard Behrenhausen (Gen. US Army, ret.) and David Buchmueller (COO of the PDN Group), who spoke with enthusiasm about the many assets of their city, and even discussed the regions challenges and misconceptions.
For example, most people are aware of El Paso’s large Mexican sister to the south – Cuidad Juarez. Wracked by drug wars and corruption, Juarez recorded over 3,000 homicides in 2010, which is easily the highest murder rate in the world.
Yet just across the Rio Grande river, El Paso remains a world apart. El Paso has the lowest violent crime rate in the United States for cities over 500,000 population, with only five homicides in 2010.
The November 6th, 2011 episode of “CBS Sunday Morning” posted its largest audience in five years, drawing nearly 6 million viewers. The lead story was based on our Sperling’s study of “Most Sleepless Cities”, which featured Louisville, KY as the worst city for getting a good night’s rest.
I’d like to believe that our compelling rankings helped to score this ratings win for CBS. Here’s a link to the story in the industry publication “Broadcast and Cable”.
I was asked by the Post to explain why the DC metro has suddenly gained so many 25-34 year olds. According to the Census Bureau, DC is now right up there with hipster havens like Austin and Portland (Oregon).
Reporter Carol Morello asked me, “Does this mean Washington is now ‘cool’?”
My answer was, “Umm, sorry, no.” I explained, it’s a simple case of economics. The DC area has had one of the lowest unemployment rates in the U.S. along large metro areas. Young people are flocking to where the jobs are.
Bill Frey, of the Brookings Institution, also chimed in, agreeing that it’s the economy, but also stating that DC has a “certain vibe.”
My quote in the article spoke about each place has its own identity or brand, and Washington’s is one of government and power. “I don’t know if you want your seat of government to be too cool and quirky.”
Sort of like, you don’t want to find out your heart surgeon also does stand-up comedy.